Musings of an Old Chemist

A Chemist's Perspective on the Habits and Skills STEM Students Need For Success

Tag: conservation of energy

  • Understanding Energy Conservation Using a “Truck on a Ramp” Scenario

    Understanding Energy Conservation Using a “Truck on a Ramp” Scenario

    The “Truck on a Ramp” model is a classic physics scenario that involves the principle of energy conservation. Its focus is on the emergency truck ramps often seen on mountain interstates. These extremely steep ramps are strategically placed to safely stop a speeding, out-of-control truck, a truck whose brakes may have failed while descending a steep mountain grade. 


    The “Truck on a Ramp” Scenario

    Assume a truck descending Interstate 1-75 through the mountains north of Chattanooga, Tennessee, is travelling 80 miles per hour (Vinitial=35.8meterssecondV_{initial} = 35.8\; \frac{meters}{second}) when its brakes fail.  What height in meters must the highest point of an emergency truck ramp be (assuming the force due to friction and air resistance is equal to zero) for the truck to come to a complete stop (Vfinal=0V_{final}=\;0)? Assume the force of gravity (Fg=9.8meterssecond2F_g=\;9.8\;\frac{meters}{second^2}). Round your answer to 22significant figures, because the value for the force of gravity, 9.8ms29.8\;\frac{m}{s^2}, has 22 significant figures.


    Background

    One of my favorite topics in science is the conservation of energy. I could teach an entire semester of an “Introduction to Chemistry and Physics” high school science course on this topic. 

    In this post, we will examine the Conservation of Mechanical Energy, one of the most powerful concepts in your physics toolbox.

    The introductory physics world often relies on ideal scenarios, telling us to “assume a frictionless system” or “neglect air resistance.” While these assumptions don’t reflect the real world, they are essential for isolating and understanding the central physical laws.

    By understanding the relationship between kinetic and potential energy in an ideal system, you gain the ability to solve complex problems without ever needing to calculate acceleration or time.


    Solution Strategy:

    In a perfect world free of non-conservative forces (like friction affecting the scenario and turning motion into heat), the total amount of mechanical energy in a system never changes. It just transforms.

    The formula: TE=KE+PE=ConstantTE = KE + PE = \text{Constant}, where the Total Energy\text {Total Energy} (TETE) is always the sum of the energy of motion (Kinetic Energy or\text{Kinetic Energy or} (PEPE)) and stored energy of position (Potential Energy or\text{Potential Energy or} PEPE). The units for energy are in Joules (J)\text{Joules (J)}

    TE=KE+PE=ConstantTE = KE + PE =\text{Constant}

    • KEKE: Energy of motion\text{Energy of motion} (12mv2\frac{1}{2}mv^2)
    • PEPE: Energy due to position (h)\text{Energy due to position (h)} (mghmgh)

    Let’s examine this transformation as our truck enters the ramp.


    Situation 1: The Bottom of the Ramp (Vinitial=maximumV_{initial}=\text{maximum})

    Imagine the truck moving at full speed right at the base of the ramp.

    At this exact moment and location, we set our reference point for height to zero (h=0\text{h=0}). Because potential energy relies on position, or height, (PE = mgh\text{PE = mgh}), if h =0 then PE = 0  Joules\text{h =0 then PE = 0\;Joules}.

    The formula for Total Energy (TE)\text{Total Energy (TE)} becomes:

    • Potential Energy  (PE)  =\text{Potential Energy\;(PE)\;=} 0  Joules\text{0\;Joules}
    • Kinetic   Energy  (KE) = Maximum\text{Kinetic \;Energy\;(KE) = Maximum} (KE)\text{(KE)}
    • Total Energy (TE): TE = KE   +   0\text{Total Energy (TE): TE = KE\; + \;0}

    Therefore, at the lowest point of the ramp, the Total Energy (TE) is entirely Kinetic Energy (KE)\text{Total Energy (TE) is entirely Kinetic Energy (KE)}. The truck is going as fast as it ever will.


    Situation 2: The Top of Ramp (Maximum Height, (Vfinal= 0 meterssecond\text{V}_{final} \text{= 0 }\;\frac{meters}{second} )

    Now, the truck races up the ramp. Gravity is doing negative work on it, slowing it down. The truck reaches its highest point and, for just a split second, it stops moving before it starts rolling back down.

    At that exact split second when velocity is zero (v=0)(v=0), the kinetic energy vanishes (KE = 12m(0)2= 0 Joules\text{KE = }\frac{1}{2}\text{m(0)}^2 \text{= 0 Joules}).

    Where did that energy go? It didn’t disappear. It transformed into gravitational potential energy. The truck is now at its maximum height (h = maximum (meters)\text{h = maximum (meters)}).

    • Kinetic Energy = 0 Joules\text{Kinetic Energy = 0 Joules}
    • Potential Energy = Maximum(PEmax)\text{Potential Energy = Maximum} \; (\text{PE}_{max})
    • Total Energy (TE): TE = 0 Joules + PEmax\text{Total Energy (TE): TE = 0 Joules + PE}_{max}

    At the highest point of the ramp,theTotal Energy (TE) is entirely Potential Energy (PE\text{Total Energy (TE) is entirely Potential Energy (PE}). This is the instant when the truck is completely stopped.


    Calculations

    Because we are in a frictionless system, we know that the Total Energy TE must be the same at the bottom and at the top.

    This gives us one of the most useful problem-solving equations in mechanics:

    Total Energy(atbottom)=Total Energy(attop)\text{Total Energy}_{(at\; bottom)} = \text{Total Energy}_{(at\; top)}

    KEmax(bottom)= PEmax(top)\text{KE}_{max\; (bottom)}\text {= PE}_{max\; (top)}

    (12m(v(initial))2)(bottom)=(mgh)(top)(\frac{1}{2}m{(v_{(initial)})}^2)\;_{(bottom)}=(mgh)\;_{(top)}

    Values from the scenario:

    Truck’s initial velocity: Vinitial=35.8meterssecond\text{Truck’s initial velocity: V}_{initial}=35.8\frac{meters}{second}

    Forceduetogravity:Fg=9.8meterssecond2Force\; due\; to \;gravity:\;F_g=9.8\frac{meters}{second^2}

    Substituting:

    12mx(35.8meterssecond)2=mx(9.8meterssecond2)xh)\frac{1}{2}m\;x\;(35.8\;\frac{meters}{second})^2 = m\;x\;(9.8\;\frac{meters}{second^2 })\;x\;h)

    Cancelling the truck’s mass (m)(m) from both sides:

    12(35.8meterssecond)2=(9.8meterssecond2)xh)\frac{1}{2}(35.8\;\frac{meters}{second})^2 = (9.8\;\frac{meters}{second^2 })\;x\;h)

    Solving for the final height (h(final))(h\;_{(final)}):

    (12)x(35.8ms)2)9.8(ms2)=h(final)\frac{(\frac{1}{2})\;x\;(35.8\;\frac{m}{s})^2)}{9.8\;(\frac{m}{s^2})}\;= h_{(final)}

    Performing the calculations:

    640.8m2s29.8ms2=h\frac{640.8\;\frac{m^2}{s^2}}{9.8\,\frac{m}{s^2}}=h

    65.4  meters = h (final)\text{65.4\;meters = h }_{(final)}

    Rounding to 22 significant figures, the final height of the ramp will need to be: 65 meters\text{65 meters} or approximately 210 feet\text{210 feet}.


    Why This is Valuable

    By understanding that in a frictionless scenario, total mechanical energy transitions between these two forms (kinetic energy and potential energy), you can skip having to use complicated kinematics equations to solve the problem.

    If you know how fast the truck was going at the bottom, you can instantly calculate exactly how to design the ramp, specifically how high the ramp needs to go.

    And, conceptually, this relationship between Total Energy, Potential Energy, and Kinetic Energy also explains why the initial hill on a roller coaster is higher than any subsequent hill or loop in the rest of the ride. 

    If you can grasp these energy exchange calculations, you’ve mastered a cornerstone of classical mechanics.

  • Personal Growth as a Series of Energy Transformations

    Personal Growth as a Series of Energy Transformations

    The Law of Conservation of Energy

    Have you ever felt completely drained after a project, even a successful one? Or, conversely, felt energized and alive after tackling a difficult challenge? The reason for this might be found in a fundamental law of the universe: the conservation of energy.

    The law of conservation of energy states that energy cannot be created or destroyed; it can only be transformed from one form to another. The principle of conservation of energy absolutely applies to the process of your personal growth. You can’t get energy out without putting energy in.

    In our chemical reaction analogy for personal growth, this principle is foundational. It means that the personal energy you have is a finite resource that must be accounted for. It can’t simply disappear.

    We can view our personal growth as a series of energy transformations. In this model, you are the most precious resource you have—your personal energy. Personal growth requires an investment of personal energy—your time, effort, focus, and emotional commitment—to initiate and sustain a change. The outcome you get is a direct result of this transformation.

    The key to living the life you desire isn’t about finding more energy; it’s about choosing where to invest the energy you have.


    Exothermic Personal Growth

    An exothermic reaction is one that releases more energy than it takes to get started. Think of a campfire: you invest a small amount of energy to light a match, but the fire then releases a much greater amount of heat and light. 

    Exothermic personal growth is a process that provides a net gain. In a highly efficient “reaction,” your invested energy is transformed into a net gain of new, positive energy. This is the ideal. It’s a process where your small, intentional investment of personal energy leads to a large and rewarding release of positive energy. 

    For example, the challenging work of learning a new skill that brings you joy, taking on a difficult but meaningful project, having a deep, honest conversation with your friend. These actions require effort, but the feeling of accomplishment, connection, and confidence you get in return is a powerful surplus. The emotional reward is far greater than the initial effort.


    Endothermic Personal Growth 

    An endothermic reaction is one that absorbs energy from its surroundings. Think of a chemical cold pack: it needs to absorb energy from the environment to become cold. The process leaves the surroundings with less energy. In a draining “reaction,” your energy is transformed into by-products like stress, frustration, and burnout. You put in a great amount of personal energy, but because the process is inefficient or misaligned with your goals, you are left feeling drained and with a net loss of energy.

    It’s when you are constantly investing a large amount of personal energy into a process or relationship, with very little emotional or mental energy being returned. This could be staying in a job that makes you miserable for too long, trying to earn the approval of someone who constantly criticizes you, or pursuing a goal out of obligation, not because you’re passionate about it. These are processes that leave you feeling drained. The energy you invest is not returned to you, or the products of the “reaction” aren’t worth the cost.


    Key Understanding

    In this analogy, you are the “chemist” of your own life. You can’t create more energy, but you can choose where to direct the energy you have. Your goal is to design a life filled with reactions where a small investment of intentional effort yields a significant release of personal energy, making the entire growth process both powerful and sustainable. To identify and pursue the exothermic reactions that fill you up and provide momentum for the next challenge. Just as importantly, you must recognize and minimize the endothermic reactions that drain your most precious resource: your personal energy.


    Personal Commentary: The Importance of Self-awareness

    I’m a perfect example of how the benefits of exothermic personal growth, such as accomplishment and confidence, can lead to negative outcomes. For much of my life, I have made the most of my God-given intelligence and my ability to grasp and explain complex concepts, gaining recognition and self-confidence. However, as this recognition grew, my self-confidence transformed into arrogance. I stopped recognizing and acknowledging my weaknesses, believing my way the the best or only way and that I no longer needed others’ help. This led me to forge ahead alone, alienating people and ultimately causing my failure. The very processes that were initially energizing became draining, leading to frustration, resentment, and the abandonment of those career paths.

    At the time, I blamed others for my setbacks. Now, with age, wisdom, and a new perspective, I realize I was my own worst enemy. This highlights the critical importance of self-awareness in navigating our lives. It shapes our perspective, ensuring we neither waste our energy nor allow positive, personal growth to become a long-term detriment. Self-awareness is the key to developing our action plan, the specific steps and habits we need to follow, the “procedure” in our chemical reaction analogy of personal growth.